The mission of the
Northern
BME 631
Structured English Immersion and Sheltered English Content Instruction
Spring ‘09
Course Packet and Syllabus
3 Credit Hours
Introduction to the Course, Basic Terminology, and Legal Background
Your work in this course consists of five modules. Your first module is a simple introduction and an exchange of introductions with three other students and your reaction to the introductory material. This introductory module, which earns 5 points, allows your instructor and your class-mates to get to know a bit about you as a person—not just as a student. In addition, the introductory module gives you some time to obtain text books and to become familiar with the requirements of the course. Please read through the requirements for all the modules BEFORE you get started on the first module. I strongly recommend that you plan your work-load carefully. You might very well decide to work on modules 4 and 5 at the same time as you do your reading for modules 2 and 3. Modules 4 and 5 are the most challenging!!! Please write all the dates when modules are due into your own personal calendar, and if for any reason you need an extension of time, make sure that you contact the instructor as soon as possible.
In this course, we will consider how language development is best structured to suit language learning through content-based instruction. We will concern ourselves with language development, content area instruction, and explicit instruction in learning strategies.
As you, no doubt, know the number of children in our schools who do not know English is steadily growing. Many of these studens are frightened and confused, but they all want to do well in their new settings. We certainly want them to do well both because we care for them as individuals, and also because we know that the future of our country depends on their success. Supporting new ELL students in settings where we teach classes of both ELLs and Native English Speakers seems particularly daunting. The ELL students need to learn English as quickly as possible so that they can function well in school both academically and socially. A language is never taught in a vacuum. There must always be “content.” We always talk, read, and write about SOMETHING. In our case, through this course, the “SOMETHING” will be school-subject content. School subjects are, after all, the “SOMETHING” that these students will need to cope with.
Since I don’t know the background you have brought to this course, I will begin by reviewing some basic ELL terminology and issues that you will later encounter in the reading of the course material. For some of you, this is just review. Nevertheless, I would appreciate your taking time to read through the material below. I believe that some of your reading will make more sense if the basic concepts below are clearly understood.
Ways of Providing Instruction of English to Speakers of Other Languages
ESL (English as a Second Language) is English taught in a
country where it is the native language. The classes consist of all ELL
learners and the goal is to improve English language proficiency both on social
and on academic levels. (These classes are sometimes referred to as ELD-English
Language Development). One example of such a process would be English taught to
immigrant adults in an
EFL (English as a Foreign Language) is English taught in
a country where another language is the native language. One example would be
English taught to high school students in
ESL Pull Out - In such a program, students spend most of their day in ordinary classes with native speakers of English. They are however “pulled out” for extra help with the English language.
Bilingual Education comes in several forms:
Transitional Bilingual Education offers students content instruction in their own language with a gradual transition into English. The goal is fluency in English with the use of the native language as a scaffold to the learning of the target language.
Maintenance Bilingual Education offers both languages throughout the grades to native speakers of a language other than English with the goal of preserving the native language and at the same time making students natively proficient in English.
Cognitive Academic Language Learning Approach (CALLA)-A model developed to meet the academic needs of ELLs in US-American Schools. It attempts to integrate language with school-subject content. It aligns content with the standard curriculum, relying heavily on scaffolding strategies. It emphasizes academic skills and aims for explicit instruction in appropriate strategies for both content and language learning.
1. Pre-Production Phase (Also referred to as The Silent Period)
Although students in this stage still cannot speak or understand the new language, they are nevertheless beginning to process the new sounds and words. This is a good time to ask students to vote their opinions by raising their hands when they agree with something, or to hold up a number, if the teacher has asked a multiple choice question.
2. Early production Phase-There is already quite a bit of understanding, and students begin to produce two-four word expressions. This is a good time to provide gapped texts. (known as cloze passages in the professional jargon)
3. Speech Emergence-Students speak in longer (though not always correct) phrases and understand a great deal more. This is a good time to introduce pair work and small group work.
4. Intermediate Fluency-ELLs in this stage can start conversations. They understand most of what is going on in the classroom and can participate in most classroom discussions. Lengthy academic readings and writing projects are, however, still very challenging. Here the full SEI and CALLA programs that you will work with begin to work beautifully.
We have been told by Cummins
(Cummins, J. Model for Empowerment of Minority Students: Implications for
Teacher Education.
Basic Interpersonal Communication Skills (BICS) and Cognitive Academic Language Proficiency (CALP).
BICS is the ability to interact with native speakers of a language in social settings. Children quickly acquire such proficiency. It allows them to play games, talk on the telephone, and interact on the playground. Children under the age of ten will usually reach this stage after only six months in a new country. Adults might take two years.
CALP is the ability to deal with academic content, reading of text-books, following lectures, writing reports, following complex instructions, and participating in academic discussions and debates.
How Languages Are Learned-Some background on Theory and Methodology
There are basically two philosophies that under-gird the methodologies of language learning. These two philosophies are the Innatist Perspective and the Behaviorist Perspective. The Innatist Perspective, whose primary proponent is Noam Chomsky, argues that human beings innately possess language learning abilities, and come pre-wired for language learning, while the behaviorist philosophy, promoted by B. F. Skinner, understands language learning as a series of imitations and habit formations.
Language learners and teachers have, over the years, decided that both of these theories have merit in the language learning process. The Charts below will give you a brief outline of how these theories operate, and which language learning methodologies they have generated. For a thorough understanding of these theories and methodologies, you will have to take a general methodology course. In this class, we will consider only content based language instruction, which certainly takes cues from both of the above mentioned theories.
Structured English Immersion (SEI) aims to facilitate both language and content study. It attempts to break subject matter into understandable chunks, make use of students’ prior knowledge, using concrete materials, direct experience, explicit strategies, and collaborative work.
The charts below are culled
from material in Peregoy, S.F. & Boyle, O.F.
(1993).
BEHAVIORIST THINKING
Known For: |
Criticisms |
Attributes |
Examples of Behaviorist Models |
Rote Learning |
Does not consider cognitive factors |
Brought order & science into language acquisition |
Skinner - Operant Conditioning. Reinforcement/reward/punishment a. signal learning b. stimulus response c. chaining |
Habit formation |
Cannot explain creativity or original speech |
Certain aspects of language must be learned by rote |
Grammar Translation |
Reward Oriented |
Lab-oriented, cannot be replicated in a natural setting |
|
Reading Approach |
INNATIST THINKING
Known For: |
Criticisms |
Attributes |
Examples of Nativist Models |
Task related |
Doesn’t advocate teaching language structure |
L2 learned in the same way as L1 |
Chomsky (Generative Transformative Approach) |
Problem oriented (problem dictates discipline to be used) |
Students don’t learn grammar rules |
Pays attention to affective filter and cognitive & sociopolitical issues |
Krashen (Monitor Model) |
Based on participatory research |
|
|
Ausubel (Meaningful Learning) |
Heavily influenced by linguistics, though influenced by psychology, sociology, etc. |
|
|
Asher (TPR)-TPR, however, also relies heavily on habit formation through repetition. |
Has a responsibility to society |
|
|
Terrell (Natural Approach) |
Language is an innate quality; we’re predisposed to language learning |
|
|
Lozano (Suggestopedia) |
Distinguishing between competence & performance |
|
|
Gattegno ( |
|
|
|
Curran (Community Language
Learning). Strongly influenced by |
|
|
|
Freire (Generative Themes) |
Below is a summary of the important court decisions that apply to ELL students –PLEASE READ AND REACT TO THESE IN YOUR FIRST MODULE
IMPORTANT COURT DECISIONS THAT APPLY
TO ELL CHILDREN
BROWN V. TOPEKA BOARD OF
EDUCATION (1954): Schools may not segregate on the basis of race, color,
or national origin. In an earlier case, Mendez v.
LAU V. NICHOLS (1974): Schools must take appropriate action to remedy the language deficiencies of all ELL children. What is ‘appropriate action’ has been debated and the Court did not specify one remedy.
PLYLER V. DOE (1982):
States may not force schools to validate the legal resident status of any child
and schools may not require proof that any child, and/or his/her parents, is
legally living in the
FLORES V. ARIZONA (2000): Arizona must mandate that all districts adopt; a uniform method to set criteria for inclusion in, and exit from, ELL programs, follow uniform proficiency standards for ELL children, and a plan to monitor all ELL programs for success at moving children out of the program. The case stemmed from the fact that ELL children routinely perform poorly on standardized tests, such as AIMS, and that the State has an unequal system to fund remedies, (see Lau) to help ELL children.
HEADING TWO: Course Syllabus
The mission of the
Northern
BME 631
Structured English Immersion and Sheltered English Content Instruction
Spring ’09—Course Syllabus
Semester: Spring ‘09
Location: WEB
Instructor: Dr. Natalie Hess
Office: NAU in
Office Hours-or by appointment. Call any time and leave me a message. I promise to get back to you just as soon as I am able
Phone: 928-317-6407
E-mail: natalie.hess@nau.edu
E-mail:
Course Prerequisites: there are no prerequisites for this course
Course Description:
The teaching of content in English to limited-English proficient students in grades K-12 using appropriate approaches, methods and techniques.
Student Learning Expectations:
Students will be able to do the following in each curricular area:
ELL Proficiency Standards Objectives
1.Describe the alignment between Arizona State Language Arts Standards and Arizona ELL Proficiency Standards.
2. Demonstrate how to use ELL Proficiency Standards to plan, deliver, and evaluate instruction.
3. Demonstrate how to integrate ELL Proficiency Standards in all content areas.
Data Analysis and Application Objectives
4 Analyze and apply disaggregated data to differentiate instruction.
5. Interpret and use snapshots of longitudinal data.
6. Align standardized testing and language proficiency assessments including the SELP to ELL standards.
Formal and Informal Assessment Objectives
7. Integrate diagnostic, formative and summative assessments for ELLs.
8. Create and offer multiple assessments.
9. Use assessment results for placement and accommodation for special education and gifted students.
10. Use standardized testing and language proficiency assessments to monitor student progress.
Foundations Objectives
11. Discuss the linguistic, academic, cultural, political, historical, and legal issues relative to the education of language minority students including the rational for SEI
12. Define basic terminology related to SEI and language minority education.
13. Discuss the role of culture in learning.
14. Define Basic Interpersonal Communication Skills (BICS) and Cognitive Academic Language Proficiency (CALP) and explain why these two concepts are significant.
15. Describe the process of second language acquisition.
SEI Strategies Objectives
16. Demonstrate multiple strategies to improve ELL achievement (comprehensible input, types of learner feedback, grouping structures and techniques, building background and vocabulary development, and student engagement.)
17. Demonstrate SEI methods for beginning ELLS (TPR Storytelling, contextual clues, narrative approach)
18. Describe the Silent Period (ways of responding, developmental process)
19. Grasp meaning of pre- and early production strategies of students.
20. Integrate current materials in ELL instruction (lesson and text modifications)
21. Extend SEI content methods (preview/review, content area reading and writing strategies, experiential methods)
22. Analyze and apply vocabulary development approaches in the content areas.
23. Plan SEI lessons based on students prior knowledge.
24. Select, adapt, and sequence curricular materials for ELLs.
Parent, Home, School Scaffolding Objectives
25. Identify the socio-cultural influences on ELLs (language shift, identity, the role of culture in learning)
26. Discuss the effects of bilingualism and home language use.
27. Describe parental and community sources for aiding English language acquisition.
28. Discuss how to cultivate home-school partnerships.
Course Structure/Approach:
The objectives will be accomplished through reading of texts, exchange of ideas with other students on the discussion board, written assignments, and completion of projects.
Required Texts: These books should be available in the
Uhl
Chamot, & O’Malley, J.M. (1994). The CALLA Handbook: Implementing the Cognitive
Academic Language Learning Approach.
Echevarria, J. Vogt, M. Short D. (2000). Making
Content Comprehensible for English Language Learners: The SIOP Model.
Recommended
Text Specifically Relating to TESOL Standards-Based Instruction:
Agor, B. (2000). Integrating the ESL Standards Into Classroom Practice: Grades 9-12. TESOL, Inc.
Irujo, S. (2000). ). Integrating the ESL Standards Into Classroom Practice: Grades 6-8. TESOL, Inc.
Davies, K. (2000). ). Integrating the ESL Standards Into Classroom Practice: Grades 3-5 TESOL, Inc.
Other Recommended books
Claire, E.
& Haynes, J. (1994). Classroom
Teacher’s ESL Survival Kit #1
Cliffs, NJ: Alemany Press, Prentice Regents Press.
Cushner, K. McLelland, A. and Safford, P. (2000). Human Diversity in Education.
Freeman, D.E., Freeman, Y.S.
(2004). Essential Linguistics: What You Need to Know to Teach
Ioga, C., (1995). The Inner World of The
Immigrant Child.
Herrell, A. & Jordan, M (2004).
Fifty Strategies for Teaching English Language Learners.
Hess, N.(2001).
Teaching Large Multilevel Classes.
Law, B. and Eckes, M. (1995).
Assessment and ESL.
Pollard, L.
& Hess, N. (1997). Zero
Prep: Ready-to-Go Activities for the Language Classroom.
Pollard, L.,
Hess, N., (2001). Herron, J. Zero
Prep forBeginners : Ready-to-Go Activities for the Language Classroom.
Richard-Amato, P. (1988). Making
It Happen: Interactions in the Second Language Classroom.
The course consists of five modules. Please note that you are given two due-dates for each module. The first one is for posting your findings on the discussion board. You will then have a week during which you are expected to interact with at least three other students. The second date is the one on which you are to send your entire module, including your report on your interaction with other students, in one attachment to the e-mail of the instructor. No late modules will be accepted except under extenuating circumstances. Please put everything into ONE DOCUMENT before you post it to the instructor. The deadline is always midnight of the stated day. Again-Please put all your work for that particular module into ONE ATTACHMENT before you e-mail it to the instructor. Remember that the first 4 modules should include a report on your interaction with three other students. Try to interact with different students during each of these modules. The instructions are a bit different for module 5. Please read those instructions below
INSTRUCTIONS FOR THE SIGNATURE ASSIGNMENT
Please note that
the last module is also the SIGNATURE ASSIGNMENT for this course, and it
will be sent to the instructor both in the
Please keep the following in mind:
· Since the signature assignment is such an important one and is evaluated on a school-wide rubric, I feel that it would be useful to have partners check each other’s work, before sending it to the instructor.
· I hope that you begin your signature assignment about
two weeks before it is due. The assignment, which is a lesson plan with
teaching and refelction, will be graded on the rubric
posted below. The lesson plan is due to the instructor to the instructor in
· Since I don’t know you, I will arbitrarily partnered you by placing you together with the student who is next to you on the alphabetical list. If you wish to make another arrangement among yourselves, please feel free to do so, but I feel strongly that you should have one other person check over your plan before you hand it in on TaskStream. Please let me know whether you have completed the exchange check, when you send me this module. At the same time, you might want to tell me just how the exchange worked. To help you succeed in creating your lesson plan, I have also included a successful examples in the section that further explains the modules. There are two lesson plan examples.
· I will create the partner list as soon as all the registration for the course finalized. There is always some shifting going on during the first weeks of the course, so please be patient.
Here are the main points that your grid demands, and that you should be looking for in you partner’s lesson plan:
1. There are both content and language objectives and these are appropriate for the level of the lesson.
2. The teacher plans on checking language level and activating prior knowledge of the students.
3. Language and content are integrated and there is evidence of scaffolding. (Helping students to understand difficult points step by step)
4. Several activities that integrate language and content are seen and the activities are built for student engagement.
5. There is evidence of supplementary material.
6. There is evidence for assessment
7. There is a smoothly described lesson sequence that can be easily followed.
8. The language is correct and follows language conventions.
9. The TESOL standards are listed.
Grading System:
a. Introduction—Module One 5 points
b. Module Two-CALLA 20 points
c. Module Three--SIOP 20 points
d. Module Four—REAL WORLD 25 points
e. Module five—Lesson Plan 30 points-Task Stream artifact
total points: 100 points
TESOL Professional Standards Evaluated in this course:
3a—Planning for Standards-Based ESL Instruction-Candidates know, understand and apply concepts, research, and best practices to plan classroom instruction in a supporting language environment for ESL students. Candidates serve as effective English Language Models, as they plan for multilevel classrooms with learners from diverse backgrounds, using standard-based ESL and content curriculum.
3b—Managing and Implementing Standards-Based ESL and Content-Based Instruction—Candidates know, manage, and implement a variety of standards-based teaching strategies and techniques for developing and integrating English listening, speaking, reading, and writing and for accessing the core curriculum. Candidates support ESOL students in accessing the core curriculum as they learn language and academic content together.
3c—Using Resources Effectively in ESL and Content Instruction—Candidates are familiar with a wide range of Standards-based materials, resources and technologies, and choose adapt, and use them effectively in ESL and Content-Based Teaching.
Due Dates for All Modules—Please put these into your personal calendar. These dates will also appear on the course calendar in VISTA
PLEASE
CONTINUE
Please send all modules as ONE attachment to the course e-mail of the instructor.
Description of the Five Modules
Module One--The Introductory Module
Introduce yourself. Tell us something about both your personal life and your professional life. Also, let us know something about your experience with school life and language learning. Write about your personal reaction to the introductory material for this course. Which theories and methodologies, and legal issues are you familiar with or have noticed in your own life in the classroom or as a language learner? If none of this is familiar to you feel free to say so! But nevertheless give us your thoughts on one or several of the issues. (About 1-2 double- spaced pages for this module.)
See due dates above in the syllabus.
How to React to Other Student Comments in all modules:
1. Names of those with whom you corresponded (At least 3)
2. Brief summary of what they said.
3. Your reaction to what they said (agreed, disagreed, found interesting, found relevant because _____________, Found unusual because_____________, found disturbing because _________)
Does not meet standard-0-1 point |
Approaches Standards2-3 points |
Meets Standard-4 points |
Exceeds Standard-5 points |
The introduction is late; language is poorly used; the required components are not met. Comments on introductory material are brief and insufficient. |
The introduction is on time and language is adequately used. Several components are in place. |
All the components (introduction, exchange with other students, and relevant comments on the introductory material) are thoughtful and use correct language conventions.The module is in on time |
The introduction and the comments regarding introductory material are clearly stated, thoughtful and following correct language conventions. There is ample and lively interaction with other students. The introduction shows clear professional interest and is engaging.The Module is in on time. |
Hello
everyone. My name is ___________________________, and I can already
recognize a few familiar names on the discussion board from other classes this
summer. I can’t wait to bounce ideas and thoughts around the discussion
boards and learn from each other. I am new to the ______________________
area as of late last summer when I accepted a teaching position in the third
grade. I arrived in town 5 days before I started school with the kids and
I have been learning under fire ever since. I am really excited about
this course because I work down in ____________ AZ and this past school year
every single one of my students was ELL. And let me tell you, coming from
the
I have to be honest when I tell you I came into the area completely oblivious about any SEI teaching strategies, so walking into a classroom full of Spanish speakers was a bit intimidating. I did have a very large gap in fluency within my class. Some children spoke both English and Spanish at home and were very confident in both, while in other situations, the English that they heard in the classroom from me was the only exposure they had all day but could keep up because of the schooling they had prior to third grade. And finally, I did have three students who didn’t speak a word of English the day they walked into my room that first day last summer. Of the three non-English speakers, one went on to be able to read and understand, just struggled to speak English, one caught on beautifully, and one left my class at the end of the year not saying a word, English or Spanish. She went into a selective state of silence which I was told later was here coping mechanism for the culture shock she was experiencing.
It was interesting to read the Levels of the Ladder to Language Learning on our syllabus because I can complete relate to every one of the levels with at least one student in my class. As far as the legal information goes that we were supposed to respond to; I find it very interesting that a school districts are required to meet the standards of the “average” Arizona student in reading, writing, and math, but the children that are labeled ELL are at an immediate disadvantage by not speaking the language they are trying to learn in. The attitude seems to be, “they will catch up eventually” but at some point doesn’t the educational system pass right by them leaving them to fend for themselves in high school and college? I would love to see the students that are brand new to the language first being taught a crash course in English, and then after they have even a little background, put them back into the mainstream learning community of their classrooms. I really think we would see so much more improvements in the long run.
It is interesting to be less than a week into this course and see how much discussion has already gone on in the discussion boards. I already know this will be a great place to throw around ideas and challenge each other to think maybe differently than we had before. Already I have had a few discussions with ____________, _____________, and ____________. It seems as though the four of us are thinking about the same things, but each have a unique view point to share. _________________ started the link on my thread to discussion my initial opinion regarding non-English speaking being pulled out of the classroom to get a crash course in learning the language. I think I misspoke myself by not explaining that I only think that should take place for a short period of time each day. That started the discussion between ______________ and me about whether or not the students will learn better or not secluded from their peers. I agree with ____________ that students will learn better when they are challenged by others that may know the language better then themselves, but I still believe that a short period of time to really teach the sounds and speech of the language would help those students catch on at a much quicker pace.
________________ , __________________, and I discussed the laws of segregation and whether or not moving children based on their fluency is fair. I know ______________ was just throwing out the question to play devils advocate, but I do not agree with her that moving students out of the class to improve their language would be segregating in the negative sense of the word. I agree with _______________________ that special education would be a good example of how moving those students into a separate learning environment is obviously beneficial for that student. Children are very understanding of their peers, I have found, when they realize their peer is getting extra help in a particular way.
Like I said, these discussions have proved to be very interesting already. I look forward to where this class will take us in challenging one another.
Read the CALLA book
Write a 1-2 double-spaced page reaction to each of the three parts. (Not to each chapter) After a brief summary of the part, choose one particular aspect that appealed to you, and that you could imagine using in your own work; explain why you have chosen this aspect and exactly how you could use. Be as specific as possible.
In section three, do the above, but also add something extra. Choose the specific field (History, Science, Math or Literature). Compare and/or contrast the CALLA way to other strategies you may have experienced as a student or as a teacher. Choose a particular technique that you could put into immediate action in the classroom that you are now teaching or observing. Tell which technique you have chosen. Describe it. Give the page number where it can be found and explain how it would fit into your classroom work. If you are not teaching right now, use an imagined classroom setting in which you can see yourself functioning. (About 1 double-spaced page) this whole module should be about 5-7 double-spaced pages.
Post only this section—your work in Section three (3) on the discussion board.
You should be sending the following to your instructor:
1. Your summaries and reaction to two CALLA sections.
2. Your special comments on the third section
3. Your report on interactions with other students
See due dates above in the syllabus.
Rubric showing how this module will be graded.
Does not meet standard-1-5 points |
Approaches Standard 6-14 points |
Meets Standard-15-17 points |
Exceeds Standard-18-20 points |
Module is late; one or more components are missing; language conventions are weak. |
Module is on time with all the components included. Language is clear and correct. Most instructions are followed. |
Module is on time with all the components included. Language is clear and correct. All instructions are followed. The material shows professional interest and relevance. |
Module is on time. Language is clear, correct, and eloquent. All the components are included. All instructions are followed. The material shows professional interest, insight to procedure, insightful response, and professional relevance. |
Read the SIOP book. Write a brief reaction to each of the 10 chapters. (About one or two paragraphs for each chapter—double Spaced) Here I definitely don’t want to see a summary, but rather a personal reaction to any of the strategies and/or the scenarios presented. Then, look over Appendix A. Choose any ONE of Observational components (i.e. Preparation, Instruction, Review and Assessment), and think back over a lesson you have recently given or that you have recently observed. Briefly describe that lesson and rate the teacher-you, or the person you observed, according to SIOP. Write a concluding paragraph explaining why and how you decided on the rating.
Post only two of your chapter reactions (your favorite chapters) on the Discussion board.
You should send your instructor the following:
1. All your chapter reactions to SIOP
See due dates above in the syllabus
How This Module Is Graded:
Does not meet standard-1-5 points |
Approaches Standard 6-14 points |
Meets Standard-15-17 points |
Exceeds Standard- 18-20 points |
Module is late; one or more components are missing; language conventions are weak. |
Module is on time with all the components included. Language is clear and correct. Most instructions are followed |
Module is on time. All the components are included. Language is clear and correct. All instructions are followed. The material shows professional interest and relevance. |
Module is on time. All the components are included. Language is clear, correct, and eloquent. All instructions are followed. The material shows professional interest, insight to procedure, insightful response, and professional relevance. |
This module involves a great deal of practical ELL work. There is not much to read, but a great deal to do. This is why I hope that you start this module while you are still reading the other two. There are three parts to this module.
1. An interview with an experienced ELL professional
2. Three hours of work with an ELL student
3. A packet consisting of 10 effective ELL teaching strategies
You will be sending your instructor all the above as well as a report on your interaction with other students.
On the discussion board you need to post only One of the above sections—You choose the one that you think represents your work the best.
.
See due dates above or in “Heading Two”—the Syllabus
Does not meet standard-1-5 points |
Approaches Standard 6-14 points |
Meets Standard-15-20 points |
Exceeds Standard- 20-25 points |
Module is late; one or more components are missing; language conventions are weak. The interview provides minimal material. The tutoring sessions do not seem to contribute much to student learning. The techniques in the packet are unclear. |
Module is on time. Language is clear and correct. All instructions are followed. The material shows professional interest and relevance. The ideas presented through the interview, the tutoring session and the strategy packet are relevant and practical for ELL. |
Module is on time. Language is clear and correct. All instructions are followed. The material shows professional interest and relevance. The interview offers practical advice. The tutoring session is clearly of benefit to the student, and shows understanding of both the material and the interaction. The techniques of the strategy packet are useful and relevant across language levels. |
Module is on time. Language is clear, correct, and eloquent. All instructions are followed. The material shows professional interest, insight to procedure, insightful response, and relevance. The interview offers examples, as well as professional insight on the part of the interviewer, as well as practical advice. The interviewee is asked for specific examples. The tutoring session is clearly beneficial to both student and instructor. The student’s background is described clearly and movingly. The techniques of the strategy packet are useful and relevant across language levels. |
a. Interview with an experienced ELL practitioner
If at all possible, choose someone who has taught ELL for at least three years. Write about the background and experience of this person. (For Reasons of Privacy—Use fictional names). You may ask your interviewee anything that you consider important and relevant, but I would prefer your finding answers to the questions listed below. (You may want to speak to more than one person in order to find the information). You could also send your question ahead of time to your interviewee, so that this person could have some time to think clearly about he answers he/she wants to give. You can report on your interview in one of two ways. You can simply use the question and answer strategy, or you can write an essay summarizing your findings. Here are my questions: (Please feel free to add your own). Try to be as specific as possible. Ask the person you are interviewing for specific examples. If they should say, “I use a lot of gestures to make my meaning clear, ask them to provide a specific example.” If your interviewee says, “I use a lot of group work.” Ask them to describe a specific instance. If he/she says, “I use gestures and pictures.” Again ask for specific examples. The whole idea here is that you should learn something new from this interview, so it is up to YOU to ask for specifics. How do they teach vocabulary? How do they organize their class? Again, don’t allow yourself to just collect generalities. We are after specific techniques here.
2. Three Hours with an ELL student
Choose an ELL student of any age and language level. Learn about the background of this person. (Where is he/she from? How long has he/she lived in the U.S?
What level of language competence has this person achieved? What is his/her greatest language problem?)
Find out how you could help this student to make some progress, and spend your remaining time in tutoring sessions. Describe these sessions in detail and tell about the progress that might have made. Describe what you learned in the three hours and what you think that your student learned. If you are a teacher, you will, no doubt, find this student in one of your own classes. If you are not teaching yet or right now, any teacher in your area will be able to supply you with a candidate.
3. The Technique packet
· This project will consist of ten (10) ELL strategies (activities) written in such a way that a substitute teacher could easily follow the activities. These should be activities that could, if adapted, be used on any level of ELL. Please look over the example packet below
· The ELL Technique project will begin with an introduction of you as a writer-Your name, the school where you teach, something about your ELL experience as either a language teacher or learner; anything personal that you wish to share and the story of your search--where you searched and why, (whom you talked to-why you chose these people-where they directed you), and the reasons for choosing your particular activities. You can search for good activities in your readings, in the recommended books, and on the WEB. Please note the WEB sites you have been given in this course at the end of this course-packet.
· Each of your activities should include the following:
1. Title
2. Explanation of what skill is practiced in the activity, what the students will actually be doing, and how you plan to use this activity in your own work
4. Materials (if needed)
5. Preparation (if needed)
6. Procedure in numbered steps.
7. Credit to source and/or explanation of how the original was accepted for your use.
To help you with your work, I have included an example of an of the introduction and two strategies from a the work of a previous student in this course.
Activities Project—Example
I am writing this for the
Literacy Strategies Project, in the Northern Arizona University BME-420 course.
My name is Kevin C. Weatherbee, and I am currently a
senior attending NAU-Yuma. I will be graduating in May of 2003 with a degree in
Elementary Education with an emphasis on Multicultural Education. I am
currently a substitute teacher for Yuma Elementary School District 1 in
As for my WEB search, I used <http://www.google.com> as my search engine, and input “ESL lesson plans” as my search parameters. I was mildly surprised by they plethora of results that came back. Most unfortunately, were either “dead” links, or of no use to me. I did find one site that I found very useful and user friendly. The website I found was <http://www.lingolex.com/userpages/Ernie.html> . This actually is just a small portion of a much larger site that is very much oriented towards ESL in general. The reasons I chose all the activities/strategies form this site is that they all appealed to me both as an educator, and as a person who enjoys these types of activities. When looking for activities like this, I put myself into the mind of the child I am trying to reach and ask “is this enjoyable and will I learn anything?” I felt that I did on all the activities I choose and modified.
I hope to actually use some of these ideas when I student teach next spring and when I teach full-time next year. I enjoyed this activity as it has opened my eyes further to what is out there for us as educators of ESL and Non-ESL students.
This activity uses the four skills of writing, listening, thinking, and speaking. This activity not only builds on teamwork but also builds strongly on vocabulary skills by having students’ use the words grammatically correct in a sentence.
AIM: vocabulary review, parts of speech review, and verb form review
MATERIALS: Vocabulary word list
White Board
White board dry erase markers
PROCEDURE:
1. Draw a nine square grid on the board and fill each box with one word.
2. Divide the class in half, and designate one half as -x- and the other half as -o-.
3. The students on each team collaborate in coming up with grammatical sentences using the vocabulary.
4. When they use a word in a correct sentence, mark either x or o over the word. Three in a row wins!
Source credit:
I found this strategy on the website <http://www.lingolex.com/userpages/Ernie.html> along with many other great strategy ideas for an ESL or regular classroom. This website also references the following items; Hewitt, I. E. EDUTAINMENT- HOW TO TEACH LANGUAGE WITH FUN AND GAMES Language Direct, Australia, 1996 / Wright, A and others - GAMES FOR LANGUAGE LEARNING Cambridge University Press, London, 1979 / Bohart , Janet - GIVE ‘EM A BREAK - handout. I did not change this strategy much at all, as I found it to be fine the way it is written. I would however, modify it for other curriculum subjects as needed.
STOP (For All Levels)
This activity uses the four skills of writing, listening, thinking, and speaking. This is a simple vocabulary game that can be played with two levels of difficulty depending on the level of the students. Students not only have to use their skill of memorization of what a word is but also how it is spelled correctly, Then they must be able to write it correctly. This is a wonderful and rewarding activity for the students.
AIM: vocabulary review
MATERIALS: White Board (1 per student)
White board dry erase markers (1 per student)
PROCEDURE:
(Easy version)
1. Draw five columns on a chalkboard.
2. Students repeat this procedure on their whiteboards
3. Assign each column a letter from the alphabet
4. Students do the same on their white boards
5. When class has accomplished this shout, Go!
6. The exercise ends when the first student to fill in all the columns with a word that begins with the letter of each column shouts, STOP!
(You can go through the whole alphabet like this and also use common two letter word beginnings like ex, sh, sp, ch, etc.... )
(More difficult version)
1. Draw five columns on a chalkboard.
2. Students repeat this procedure on their whiteboards
3. Assign each of the five columns a general category like food, clothing, emotions, office items, things in the house, etc....
4. Have students repeat this procedure on their whiteboards
5. You then call out a letter from the alphabet.
6. Students have to fill each column with
a vocabulary word that begins with the letter and pertains to the category
The exercise ends when the first student to fill in all
the columns with a word that begins with the letter of each column
shouts, STOP!
Source credit:
I found this strategy on the website <http://www.lingolex.com/userpages/Ernie.html> along with many other great strategy ideas for an ESL or regular classroom. This website also references the following items; Hewitt, I. E. EDUTAINMENT- HOW TO TEACH LANGUAGE WITH FUN AND GAMES Language Direct, Australia, 1996 / Wright, A and others - GAMES FOR LANGUAGE LEARNING Cambridge University Press, London, 1979 / Bohart , Janet - GIVE ‘EM A BREAK - handout. I did change this strategy a bit, to have more individual student involvement. This strategy could be used in a small group setting or a whole classroom at once. I might consider modifying it for other curriculum subjects as needed such as science, or social studies.
Module 5—Signature Assignment –To be posted on Task Stream
Please send all modules in as ONE attachment to the course e-mail of the instructor.
The Lesson Plan with Teaching and Reflection Components
INSTRUCTIONS FOR THE SIGNATURE ASSIGNMENT
Please note that the
last module is also the SIGNATURE ASSIGNMENT for this course, and it
will be sent to the instructor both in the
Please keep the following in mind:
· Since the signature assignment is such an important one and is evaluated on a school-wide rubric, I feel that it would be useful to have partners check each other’s work, before sending it to the instructor.
· I hope that you begin your signature assignment about
two weeks before it is due. The assignment, which is a lesson plan with a
teaching and a reflection component (You may, if you wish, use the SIOP model) will be graded on the rubric posted below. The lesson
plan is due to the instructor both in
· Since I don’t know you, I have arbitrarily partnered you by placing you together with the student who is next to you on the alphabetical list. If you wish to make another arrangement among yourselves, please feel free to do so, but I feel strongly that you should have one other person check over your plan before you hand it in on TaskStream. Please let me know whether you have completed the exchange check, when you send me this module. At the same time, you might want to tell me just how the exchange worked. To help you succeed in creating your lesson plan, I have also included two successful examples below.
Here are the main points that your rubric demands, and that you should be looking for in you partner’s lesson plan:
1. There are both content and language objectives and these are appropriate for the level of the lesson.
2. The teacher plans on checking language level and activating prior knowledge of the students.
3. Language and content are integrated and there is evidence of scaffolding. (Helping students to understand difficult points step by step).
4. Several activities that integrate language and content are seen and the activities are built for student engagement.
5. There is evidence of supplementary material.
6. There is evidence for assessment
7. There is a smoothly described lesson sequence that can be easily followed.
8. The language is correct and follows language conventions.
9. The TESOL Professional Standards are listed. (These are the standards demanded of you as a “candidate.”
TESOL Professional Standards Evaluated in this course:
3a—Planning for Standards-Based ESL Instruction-Candidates know, understand and apply concepts, research, and best practices to plan classroom instruction in a supporting language environment for ESL students. Candidates serve as effective English Language Models, as they plan for multilevel classrooms with learners from diverse backgrounds, using standard-based ESL and content curriculum.
3b—Managing and Implementing Standards-Based ESL and Content-Based Instruction—Candidates know, manage, and implement a variety of standards-based teaching strategies and techniques for developing and integrating English listening, speaking, reading, and writing and for accessing the core curriculum. Candidates support ESOL students in accessing the core curriculum as they learn language and academic content together.
3c—Using Resources Effectively in ESL and Content Instruction—Candidates are familiar with a wide range of Standards-based materials, resources and technologies, and choose adapt, and use them effectively in ESL and Content-Based Teaching.
This module could be checked by your partner any during the early part of the course. The official date to submit it to a partner is Friday, April the 17th. The module should be posted to the instructor no later than Friday, April the 25th . Look in https://www.taskstream.com/pub/ for TaskStream instructions.
I will post a partner list as soon as all the registration for the course has settled. There is always a great deal of shifting, dropping and re-taking during the first few weeks of the course, so please be patient. I will send out a partner list just as soon as I can.
Your lesson plan should relate to the following TESOL Professional Standards:
The TESOL Professional Standards:
3a—Planning for Standards-Based ESL Instruction-Candidates know, understand and apply concepts, research, and best practices to plan classroom instruction in a supporting language environment for ESL students. Candidates serve as effective English Language Models, as they plan for multilevel classrooms with learners from diverse backgrounds, using standard-based ESL and content curriculum.
3b—Managing and Implementing Standards-Based ESL and Content-Based Instruction—Candidates know, manage, and implement a variety of standards-based teaching strategies and techniques for developing and integrating English listening, speaking, reading, and writing and for accessing the core curriculum. Candidates support ESOL students in accessing the core curriculum as they learn language and academic content together.
3c—Using Resources Effectively in ESL and Content Instruction—Candidates are familiar with a wide range of Standards-based materials, resources and technologies, and choose adapt, and use them effectively in ESL and Content-Based Teaching.
Please see the rubric below for how this module will be evaluated. Keep in mind that you are teaching both content and language. Your reading should have given you many ideas on how to combine language teaching with content.
I would like to remind you that additional help for your specific level can be found in the TESOL books recommended in your syllabus.
If you are not teaching at this time, please contact an ESL teacher in your area—perhaps the professional that you interviewed for a possibility trying out your lesson in this person’s class.
Description of the Lesson Plan
Artifact: Lesson Plan, Needs Assessment, Assessment of Student Learning, Evaluation of lesson plan and Reflective essay.
Lesson Plan:
Develop a Structured English Immersion lesson appropriate to the community where you teach in a content area you teach using a lesson plan form which includes: Grade/Class/ ability level/ background/Subject, Standards, Theme, Lesson Topic, Content Objectives, Language Objectives, Key Vocabulary, Supplementary Materials, Grouping Option, Assessment and Lesson Sequence. Use the lesson plan form in SIOP: Making Content Comprehensible. For Content specific standards, check the Web site of Arizona Department of Education. You may also use any one of the lesson plans suggested by TaskStream, but please make sure that all the components are clearly labeled.
Lesson:
Teach the lesson to a group of English Learners.
Evaluation:
Evaluate Preparation, Building Background, Comprehensible Input, Clear Explanation of Academic Tasks, Strategies, Interaction, Practice/Application, Effectiveness of Lesson Delivery, and Student Engagement using the form suggested by SIOP
Reflective Essay:
Write a reflection on this lesson. Why is it necessary and desirable to teach such a lesson? Explain how all four language skills were used in this lesson. What did your students learn from this lesson? How do you know they learned this? How is this student learning reflective of the language standards for this lesson? What did not work well for student learning? What would you change to improve the lesson so it better supports EL students’ language objectives? How might you change the lesson should you teach it a second time? (length—about 2-3 double spaced pages). Make sure that the sequence of your lesson is clearly developed, so that I can follow it as it would evolve in the classroom. See the example below.
Rubric for TESOL Standards 3.a. 3.b 3.c.
Planning, Managing and Implementing Standards-Based ESL and Content Instruction
Standard |
Approaches Standard |
Meets Standard |
Exceeds Standard |
3.a. Planning for standards-based ESL and Content Instruction
|
Candidates are aware of content objectives and language objectives. Objectives are inappropriate for age and educational background of students. |
• Candidates plan content and language objectives. Objectives are appropriate for age and educational background of students. |
Candidates plan clearly defined language objectives. Content objectives are appropriate for age and educational background level of students. The lesson is designed for a classroom with multilevel learners from diverse backgrounds. |
3.a. Planning based on assessment of language proficiency |
Candidates are aware of students’ language proficiency. Lesson does not include review of key concepts. |
Candidates plan lesson based on assessment of students’ language proficiency and prior knowledge. Lesson includes a review of key concepts |
Candidates plan students’ learning experiences based on assessment of language proficiency and prior knowledge. Candidates conduct assessment of student comprehension and learning of all lesson objectives throughout the lesson. |
3.b. Organize learning around standards-based language learning objectives.
|
• Candidates are familiar with standards relevant to ESL and content instruction. Lesson delivery does not clearly support language objectives.
|
• Candidates clearly support content and language objectives by lesson delivery. Candidates provide opportunities for students to use strategies. |
• Candidates integrate content and language objectives by lesson delivery. Candidates provide scaffolding techniques throughout the lesson assisting and supporting student understanding. |
3.b. Provide activities and materials that integrate listening, speaking, reading and writing.
|
• Candidates are aware that integrated learning activities build meaning through practice. Candidate uses activities that integrate some language skills. |
Candidate uses activities that integrate all language skills (i.e. reading, writing, speaking and listening)
|
Candidates design activities that integrate all language skills and content areas through thematic and inquiry-based units. |
3.c. Use resources effectively in ESL and content instruction |
• Candidates recognize EL students’ various approaches to learning. No significant adaptation of content to all levels of student proficiency. |
Candidates use supplementary materials. Candidates adapt content to all levels of student proficiency. |
Candidates use supplementary materials to a high degree making the lesson clear and meaningful (e.g., computer programs, graphs, models, visuals) Candidates adapt content to all levels of student proficiency in a supportive classroom environment. |
Date: Grade/Class/Subject: 6th grade/ 4th grade ability
Unit/Theme: Functional text
Background: This is not normally my class. I do not have an all ELL class so I taught in a co- teacher’s classroom for a couple of days. I made sure to come in there and help out a little before I taught so that the students would be more comfortable with me and I felt like I knew the students better. It was a great experience for everyone.
State Standards: 4th and 6th grade
Concept 2: Functional Text Identify, analyze, and apply knowledge of the purpose, structures, clarity, and relevancy of functional text.
TESOL Professional Standards:
3a—Planning for Standards-Based ESL Instruction-Candidates know, understand and apply concepts, research, and best practices to plan classroom instruction in a supporting language environment for ESL students. Candidates serve as effective English Language Models, as they plan for multilevel classrooms with learners from diverse backgrounds, using standard-based ESL and content curriculum.
3b—Managing and Implementing Standards-Based ESL and Content-Based Instruction—Candidates know, manage, and implement a variety of standards-based teaching strategies and techniques for developing and integrating English listening, speaking, reading, and writing and for accessing the core curriculum. Candidates support ESOL students in accessing the core curriculum as they learn language and academic content together.
3c—Using Resources Effectively in ESL and Content Instruction—Candidates are familiar with a wide range of Standards-based materials, resources and technologies, and choose adapt, and use them effectively in ESL and Content-Based T
Content Objectives: After reading a series of map and directions students will be able to demonstrate a basic understanding of the importance of functional text. Students will become familiar with their own neighborhood.
Language Objective: Students will be able to demonstrate an understanding of sequence by reading, writing, and following a functional text. Students will demonstrate comprehension by following directions accurately and understand the imperative form.
KEY VOCABULARY SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIALS
Maps
Students will have a map of
Key
Receipt
Directions
_ Adaptation of Content X Modeling __Whole class
X Links to Background X Guided practice __Small groups
X Links to Past Learning X Independent practice X Partners
X Strategies incorporated __Comprehensible input X Independent
X Reading X Hands-on X Individual
X Writing X Meaningful __Group
X Speaking X Linked to objectives X Written
X Listening X Promotes engagement __Oral
Lesson Sequence:
1) Has all of the students
open up their maps of |
Students will open map and write down important items on the map. |
2) Teacher will have the students say out loud what they think is important and write it down on the board. Then the teacher will tell the student what some of the key items are if the students didn’t already name them. |
Students will share their answers with the class and record any new items that they did not think of. |
3) Teacher will then ask the student to locate the school on the map and to circle it. |
Students will circle the location of the school on the map. |
4) Then the teacher will ask the students to locate their house or neighborhood and circle it also. |
Students will circle the location of their home on the map |
5) Then the teacher will ask the students to highlight the fastest route to school from their house. |
Students will draw a line with a highlighter from their house to the school using the fastest route possible. |
6) Will ask the students to then write the directions of the route they just highlighted on the map in order to tell a classmate how to get to their home from the school. |
Students will write the directions in sequence from the time of leaving their driveway until they arrive at school. |
7) Teacher will continue to walk around the classroom and help the students when necessary. |
Students will continue to write down the direction from their house to school and if they are in need of help shall raise their hand to ask the teacher. |
8) Teacher will tell the students to share their map and directions will their partners and to look to see if the directions and route make sense and if that route is in fact the fastest. |
Students will finish the directions and then share with their partners check to see if it is the fastest route and if the directions make sense. |
9) When it looks like most students
have finished the teacher will then put up the overhead of the map of |
Students will finish up discussions with their partner and then wait for further directions from the teacher. |
10) The teacher will ask for volunteers to come forward. |
Students will volunteer to go up to the whiteboards and draw their routes and explain their directions. |
11) Teacher while student volunteer is at the front board will ask the student to circle another location (for example a local grocery store or fast food restaurant) |
Students will draw their route. Then they will draw the new location that the teacher gave to them. |
12) Teachers will ask the students to think about the fastest route to that location from the school. Then the teacher will ask the students to volunteer one direction to take to get there. |
The students will think about the fastest route to this new location and to volunteer a direction to take. |
13) The teacher will then instruct the students to line up at the door and will lead them to the computer lab. |
Students will line up and go to the computer lab. |
14) The teacher will tell the student to log on to the computers and go to yahoomaps.com |
Students will go to yahoomaps.com |
15) The teacher will then tell the students to type in their information and the schools address on the other side of the web page and to click on the get directions link. |
Students will type in all of the necessary information into the boxes and then click the link that says get directions. |
16) Teacher will tell the students to print out the map and directions form their house to school. Then will have the students line up and go back to class. |
Students will print out the map and directions. Then they will line up and go back to class. |
17) Teacher will tell students to compare the directions that they wrote to those the yahoo maps told them to take. Then the teacher will have the students staple the maps and directions together. |
Students will compare the directions and staple together everything. |
18) Teacher will then collect the maps and the directions to check for accuracy |
Students will hand in maps and directions. |
19) Teacher will then ask the students to think about their favorite food and write down in the homework calendar to go home and write the direction on how to make it. |
Students will write down their homework. |
20) Teacher will also ask the students to write down the directions on how to make a peanut butter and jelly sandwich to hand in. Then tells the students that the teacher will be making them all peanut butter and jelly sandwiches tomorrow based on their directions. |
Students write down the directions and hand it in. |
Reflections: This lesson gives students the ability to use information that is needed for them to read maps or cook books and other forms of functional text. It allows the EL students to use what language skills they have acquired to write these forms because most maps and cookbooks are not written with advanced sentences or language. It will also allow the students to see how big their town and neighborhoods are.
Evaluation:
I. Preparation
1. Content Objectives 4
2. Language Objectives 4
3. Content Concepts 3
4. Supplementary Materials 3
5. Adaptation of Content 3
6. Meaningful Activities 3
II. Instruction
Building Background
7. Concepts Explicitly Linked 3
8. Links Explicitly Made 4
9. Key Vocabulary Emphasized 2 (needed to go over more)
Comprehensible Input
10. Speech 3 (I need to go slower)
11. Explanation of Academic Tasks 4
12. Techniques 4
Strategies
13. Strategies Used 3
14. Scaffolding 3
15. Higher Order Questioning 3
Interaction
16. Interaction 4
17. Grouping Configurations 2 ( they weren’t in groups)
18. Wait Time 4
19. Clarify Key Concepts 4
Practice and Application
20. Hands-On 4
21. Apply Content and Language Knowledge 4
22. Language Skills 4
Lesson Delivery
23. Content Objectives 4
24. Language Objectives 4
25. Student Engagement 4
26. Pacing 3
Review/Assessment
27. Review of Key Vocabulary 2
28. Review of Key Concepts 3
29. Feedback 2 ( on the yahoo direction site needed more feedback)
30. Assessment 3
Reflective Essay:
I actually taught this lesson to fellow 6th grade SEI class that was
held during my planning period. I do not have all ELL’s.
So I chose a 6th grade SEI class to carry out this plan. It took a
couple of class periods to completely go through it. The type of skills that
the students learned in this lesson are life skills that are important to them
at all times in their lives. Students should know directions in general of how
to get to their house incase they ever get lost or if a family member or police
officer has to take them home. If it was an emergency situation students should
learn the quickest and most efficient route to get home. Understanding how to
read functional text is vital to the students academically and in life students
should be able to problem solve and figure out the best route from one place or
the route they should take to different places. This lesson is fun to teach
because it is so important to teach students these important life skills. For
English learners they need to know the correct words to relay information to
the general public or how to ask for directions and understand what the people
are saying back. When I lived in
The students learned how to discern the quickest way from school to their house. They learned how to read maps. They learned directions. Most importantly they learned how to problem solve. They also learned that when giving directions you need to be exact so that others do not get confused. I know the students learned this because at first they had a hard time explaining directions and it would be easy to get lost by what they said. But by the end and especially the next day when the students had to write the directions to make a peanut butter and jelly sandwich, the students learned that vague unclear directions are not going to get them results. It is all about being precise. I could actually see the improvement from one day to the next. Students were able to understand how to make better directions from other students mistakes.
I really feel as if the students language was bettered by this lesson. I saw a huge amount of students who were shy and almost non responsive at the beginning to becoming more confident as they did trials and errors and I saw their fluency increase. Students need to learn these basics. I also saw that these Language Learners because they were interested in the lesson and it directly affected them they took more control of their learning and tried harder.
The yahoo activity was a bit shaky. It was good to give the students the tools to use the internet and how to look up directions. But also sometimes the Yahoo is not completely accurate on their directions and therefore it can sometimes take them down routes and streets that students have never heard of and therefore, the students struggled a bit with this. And it for a few moments made it more confusing and frustrating for students.
To improve the lesson for ELLs I might move a bit slower in the beginning. I noticed that the first time around students were struggling with the right vocabulary. I might also present the vocabulary prior such as, North, South, Central, Turn, Go straight. Hang a left etc. I think that this might have suited the ELL’s better.
Overall to improve the lesson I would probably try to slow down the lesson and make it last a few days and include the Yahoo component but spend more time teaching about internet directions and so the students become more affluent in this area. These are great internet skills to learn but I needed to make sure to spend some time and discuss it more. Rather than only discussing problems with those students that ran into problems. I definitely would incorporate more vocabulary teaching opportunities so that the students could really benefit more fluidly from the significant and crucial vocabulary.
Example Two:
Background:
I do not have a regular teaching position but have Substitute taught for several years.
This semester I have been fortunate to work with a group of 5th/ 6th grade boys who are writing at a 2nd and 3rd grade level of comprehension. One of these boys is an English Language Learner. Because I have spent a great deal of time with these young men they were willing to participate in the activities I presented.
State Standards: 2nd Grade
22
Concept 5: Publishing Publishing includes formatting and presenting a final product for the intended audience. |
|
|
Stran
Strand 2: Writing Components
Concept 1: Ideas and Content Writing is clear and focused, holding the reader’s attention throughout. Main ideas stand out and are developed by strong support and rich details. Purpose is accomplished. |
|
|
Concept 4: Word Choice Word choice reflects the writer’s use of specific words and phrases to convey the intended message and employs a variety of words that are functional and appropriate to the audience and purpose. |
|
|
Concept 6: Conventions Conventions address the mechanics of writing, including capitalization, punctuation, spelling, grammar and usage, and paragraph breaks. |
Cr
|
CC
Goal 1, Standard 3
To use English to communicate in social settings:
Students will use learning strategies to extend their communicative competence
TESOL Standards
3a—Planning for Standards-Based ESL Instruction-I know, understand and apply concepts, research, and best practices to plan classroom instruction in a supporting language environment for ESL students. Candidates serve as effective English Language Models, as they plan for multilevel classrooms with learners from diverse backgrounds, using standard-based ESL and content curriculum.
3b—Managing and Implementing Standards-Based ESL and Content-Based Instruction—I know, manage, and implement a variety of standards-based teaching strategies and techniques for developing and integrating English listening, speaking, reading, and writing and for accessing the core curriculum. Candidates support ESOL students in accessing the core curriculum as they learn language and academic content together.
3c—Using Resources Effectively in ESL and Content Instruction—I am familiar with a wide range of Standards-based materials, resources and technologies, and choose adapt, and use them effectively in ESL and Content-Based Teaching.
Content Objectives:
After discussing the definition
of Noun, Verb,
and Adjective the students will be able to
use a color- coded system to underline 20 nouns,
10 verbs and 10
adjectives from the newspaper on day one. The following day the
students will demonstrate their recognition of nouns,
verbs, and adjectives
by completing a word search. On the third day the students will complete
a
Language Objective:
Students will be able to demonstrate an understanding of the difference between nouns, verbs and adjectives by writing sentences using nouns, verbs and adjectives properly.
Noun Part of Speech
Verb
Adjective
*** Due to behavior management issues and attention span issues with this group of students, I thought it most prudent to break the lesson up into multiple days.
SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIALS
Newspaper
Word Search
Construction Paper
Colored Pens and Pencils
Dictionary
Lesson Preparation
__X___Content Objectives prepared
__X___ Language Objectives prepared
__X___ Supplementary Materials prepared
__X___ Meaningful Activities prepared
Building Background
__X__ Concept linked to student’s background experience
____ Link between past learning and new concept
__X__ Key Vocabulary emphasized
Comprehensible Input
__X__Speech appropriate for students
__X__ Clear explanation of academic task…(written down, stated verbally)
____ Variety of techniques used to make content concepts clear
Strategies
____Opportunity to use learning strategy…(Think-Pair-Share)
__X__Scaffolding
____ Higher Order Questions asked
Interaction
__X__Interaction between student/teacher, student/student
__X__Grouping…(whole class instruction, partners, individual work)
__X__Wait time allowed
__X__ Ability to clarify concepts in L1
Practice/Application
__X__ Hands on materials provided
__X__ Activities integrate all language skills
Lesson Delivery
__X__Content Objectives supported by lesson
__X__Language Objectives supported by lesson
__X__High level of student engagement
____ Appropriate pacing of lesson
Review/Assessment
__X__ Review of key vocabulary
__X__ Review of key content concepts
____ Feedback provided
__X__ Assessment of student comprehension and learning
Before the lesson:
Write down the Learning Objective as: I will be able to identify nouns, verbs and adjectives from an article in the newspaper.
Write down the Language Objective as: I will be able to discuss with my classmates the nouns, verbs and adjectives I located.
Write down numbered instructions for what the boys should do:
1)Underline 20 nouns
2)Underline 10 verbs
3)Underline 10 adjectives
Set out Newspapers and colored pencils.
This activity lasted approximately twenty minutes.
Before the Lesson:
Write down the Learning Objective as: I will be able to identify nouns, verbs and adjectives.
Write down the Language Objective as: I will be able to write five 7-Up sentences using vocabulary words.
Write down key vocabulary:
Noun Dog
Verb
Run
Adjective Yellow
Part of Speech
The words were color-coded for visual learners, “dog” was circled, “run” underlined, and “yellow” had a box around it.
Put a sample of the worksheet on the white-board with some of the words already circled, underlined, etc in the correct color.
Write down numbered instructions for what the students should do:
1) Put name on paper
2) Circle each noun with a red pencil
3) Underline each verb with a green pencil
4) Put a box around each adjective with an orange pencil.
5) Work with a partner
6) Pick 5 words from the worksheet and write 5 7-Up sentences
The Lesson
***Modifications
One of the students reads at a much lower level than the others. He worked with an aid to do one column only of the handout.
A second student needed me to fold his paper in thirds and read the words to him. With this assistance he was able to finish the worksheet.
I had intended for the students to use five words in seven-up sentences. However I realized that they were struggling with the concept “part of speech” and how this related to the word being a noun, verb or adjective. I modified the lesson about twenty minutes into it to have the boys pick five words to write “friendly” definitions for and look up there part of speech in the Children’s dictionary.
This activity lasted thirty minutes
Day Three
Before Lesson:
Write down Learning Objective as: I will be able to
complete a
Write down Language Objective as: I will be able to
read my sentences and explain my pictures from my
Write down key vocabulary:
Noun
Verb
Adjective
Four-Square
Part of Speech
Put a sample worksheet on the white-board of the
Write down numbered instructions for what the students should do:
1) Put names on paper
2) Choose Five vocabulary words
3) Complete
4) Share your sentence and your picture with your partner
The Lesson
This activity lasted thirty minutes.
***See scanned samples of student work***
I. Preparation
1. Content Objectives 3
2. Language Objectives 4
3. Content Concepts 3
4. Supplementary Materials 4
5. Adaptation of Content 3
6. Meaningful Activities 4
Instruction
Building Background
7. Concepts Explicitly Linked 3
8. Links Explicitly Made 2
9. Key Vocabulary Emphasized 4
Comprehensible Input
10. Speech 3
11. Explanation of Academic Tasks 4
12. Techniques 2
Strategies
13. Strategies Used 2
14. Scaffolding 4
15. Higher Order Questions 2
Interaction
16. Interaction 4
17. Grouping Configurations 4
18. Wait Time 4
19. Clarify Key Concepts 3
Practice and Application
20. Hands On 4
21. Apply Content and Language Knowledge 4
22. Language Skills 3
Lesson Delivery
23. Content Objectives 4
24. Language Objectives 3
25. Student Engagement 4
26. Pacing 4
Review/Assessment
27. Review of Key Vocabulary 4
28. Review of Key Concepts 4
29. Feedback 3
30. Assessment 3
Reflection:
This was the first time I was responsible for creating a lesson plan. I have been substitute teaching for several years. However as a substitute I was only responsible for following a set of directions, versus deciding what concept to teach and how to teach it. Fortunately, I have been working with a group of emotionally handicapped fifth and sixth grade boys who are familiar and comfortable with me. They have varying degrees of language skills. One of the boys is an ELL. I wrote the lesson with this particular student in mind. Due to the nature of the boys’ disabilities I decided to break up my lesson, Chunk and Chew, into three days.
The newspaper activity the boys did on Day One is part of their current events
that they do every week. The activity allowed the boys to work together
looking for nouns, etc while also allowing them to discuss topics important to
When I presented the worksheet to the senior aid she asked what grade level the worksheet was meant for. When I told her the worksheet was for the ELL student she told me there were too many words for him. We decided to fold his paper and only have him do one column. We made a modification for one other student who was able to do the work if we folded the paper in thirds and did one column at a time, reading the words out loud to him.
I had intended for the boys to use Think-Pair-Share while finding their words. Sometimes they are willing to work together, other times not. I had also hoped that they would be able to locate all the words and then write the 7-Up sentences in approximately thirty minutes. At the end of the thirty minutes I wanted all the students to read their sentences out loud, either to an aid, to myself or to the class so they could practice their academic language. About twenty minutes into the lesson I realized they were reaching a frustration level. I modified the end of the Day Two lesson and asked that they write five “friendly” definitions for words found in the worksheet. (I felt comfortable doing this because even as a sub sometimes lessons do not go exactly as we think they might. I have had to modify a teacher’s lesson in the past.) While they did show their work to the aids, no one read their work out loud that day. The boys did collaborate to work on the worksheet. They did discuss with each other what nouns, etc they had found.
I was amazed at how quickly the time allotted went by. Reading out loud the Concept Objective, Language Objective, Key Vocabulary, and written instructions while also showing them the example of the worksheet took at least five minutes. They were not familiar with this practice, however they paid attention as I did these steps. They also stopped to me to question me about what “Part of Speech” was, which made me believe they were listening. I told them that I wanted them to work together, that we help learn better when we help teach each other. However I did not explain to them explicitly that I was going to teach them the Learning Strategy Think-Pair-Share.
When I originally wrote my lesson plan I had intended for the boys to use the
five words they had picked on Day Two and write a story on Day Three with an
illustration. However I thought they would benefit more from doing a
I feel confident that my Lesson Plan incorporated the four language skills of listening, reading, writing and speaking. These skills are especially important to this group of students to be productive citizens as they continue to grow. With the disabilities they have, they are already behind the curve. They need to know how to read and write in order to fill out a job application as well as continue their education. These students are lacking language basics that are necessary to continue their growth. I want them to feel confident in their writing and speaking abilities, which is why I chose teaching Language Arts. I was able to incorporate many of the SIOP features. To my surprise many of these features came easy. On the Evaluation, the features I found easy to incorporate I gave myself 4’s. The features that I was less comfortable with are features I have struggled with this entire semester. These are: Links Explicitly Made, Techniques, Strategies Used and Higher Order Questions. I believe with more training and more experience I will become more confident in my ability to incorporate these SIOP features.
Some Useful WEB Sites
http://www.everythingESL.net
Dave's ESL Cafe
<http://www.pacificnet.net/~sperling/eslcafe.html>
... The Internet's
the World!". "It's only words . . . ...
Dave's ESL Cafe in the Bangkok Post! ...
www.pacificnet.net/~sperling/eslcafe.html - 13k - Cached
<http://216.239.53.100/search?q=cache:_ajxgT8KwsIC:www.pacificnet.net/~sperling/eslcafe.html+ESL&hl=en&ie=UTF-8>
- Similar pages
<http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&q=related:www.pacificnet.net/~sperling/eslcafe.html>
Interesting
Things for ESL Students <http://www.manythings.org/>
www.ManyThings.org. Interesting
Things for ESL Students A fun study site
for students of English as a Second Language. Word games, puzzles ...
Description: Includes quizzes, games, and puzzles to help students learning english.
Category: Kids and Teens > School Time >
English > English as a Second Language
<http://directory.google.com/Top/Kids_and_Teens/School_Time/English/English_as_a_Second_Language/?il=1>
www.manythings.org/ - 8k - Cached
<http://216.239.53.100/search?q=cache:fIaAT8iAibUC:www.manythings.org/+ESL&hl=en&ie=UTF-8>
- Similar pages
<http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&q=related:www.manythings.org/>
English as 2nd
Language <http://esl.about.com/mbody.htm>
... http://www.sipuebla.com (Cost to Advertiser: $0.21).
esl.about.com/mbody.htm - 30k - Cached
<http://216.239.53.100/search?q=cache:uxWI8yliuE4C:esl.about.com/mbody.htm+ESL&hl=en&ie=UTF-8>
- Similar pages
<http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&q=related:esl.about.com/mbody.htm>
ESL
Magazine--Subscribe Today! <http://www.eslmag.com/>
Welcome to the award-winning service of ESL Magazine, the print magazine
for English as a second or foreign language educators! Current
Issue. ...
Description: Print publication offers overview of its current issue, highlights
of previous issues, subscription...
Category: Arts > Education > ... >
Publications > Magazines and E-zines
<http://directory.google.com/Top/Arts/Education/Language_Arts/English/English_as_a_Second_Language/Publications/Magazines_and_E-zines/?il=1>
www.eslmag.com/ - 16k - Cached
<http://216.239.53.100/search?q=cache:NFyCOCTjBNkC:www.eslmag.com/+ESL&hl=en&ie=UTF-8>
- Similar pages
<http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&q=related:www.eslmag.com/>
Self-Study
Quizzes for ESL Students (English Study Materials, ESL ...
<http://www.aitech.ac.jp/~iteslj/quizzes/>
a4esl.org. Self-Study Quizzes for ESL Students.
... There are about 1,000 of
these "HTML-only quizzes" on our Activities for ESL Students
website. ...
www.aitech.ac.jp/~iteslj/quizzes/ - 4k - Cached
<http://216.239.53.100/search?q=cache:cuUXn5qa7EYC:www.aitech.ac.jp/~iteslj/quizzes/+ESL&hl=en&ie=UTF-8>
- Similar pages
<http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&q=related:www.aitech.ac.jp/~iteslj/quizzes/>
ESL PartyLand <http://www.eslpartyland.com/>
... com. Karin's ESL PartyLand Launched
March 1, 1999. Awards & Memberships:
PartyLand is included in the Blue Web'n
library. "Inclusion ...
Description: Fun site with over 75 interactive quizzes, 15 discussion forums
and topic-based learning pages for...
Category: Arts > Education > Language Arts
> English > English as a Second Language
<http://directory.google.com/Top/Arts/Education/Language_Arts/English/English_as_a_Second_Language/?il=1>
www.eslpartyland.com/ - 10k - Cached
<http://216.239.53.100/search?q=cache:8oZjHJsiiY8C:www.eslpartyland.com/+ESL&hl=en&ie=UTF-8>
- Similar pages
<http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&lr=&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&q=related:www.eslpartyland.com/>
http://www.rif.org/what/winter_holiday03.mspx